What Are My Options for an Old or Broken Car in Canada?

When you car is broken down or no longer running, it can become a hassle.  It’s non-functional and taking up space in your driveway, but figuring out what to do next can feel overwhelming.  Repairs are expensive, selling privately takes time, and many people don’t even know where to start.

In Canada, there are several common paths people take when dealing with an old or broken vehicle. Each option comes with its own advantages and drawbacks, depending on the condition of the car, how quickly a decision needs to be made, and whether financial return is a priority.

Private Selling

Selling a car privately through platforms such as Facebook Marketplace or Kijiji is a widely used option. For vehicles that still run and are in fair condition, private sales can sometimes result in a higher payout compared to other methods.

However, private selling requires a significant time commitment. Owners are responsible for creating listings, responding to messages, arranging viewings, and negotiating price. It’s also common to encounter no-shows, low offers, or buyers who lose interest once they learn about mechanical issues.

For cars that no longer run or require major repairs, private selling can be difficult. Many buyers are hesitant to take on vehicles with unknown problems, which often leads to extended listing times or no sale at all.

Trade It In 

Ready to buy a new car?  Trading in a vehicle at a dealership is another option, particularly for those already planning to purchase a replacement car. This approach is generally straightforward and requires minimal effort from the seller.

The main limitation of trade-ins is value. Dealerships typically offer lower amounts for older or damaged vehicles, especially if they are not roadworthy. In addition, this option is usually only available if a new or used car is being purchased at the same time.

Donating the Vehicle

Some owners choose to donate their old vehicle to a charitable organization. Many Canadian charities accept cars in various conditions and arrange for pickup.

Donation may be appealing for those who are less concerned about financial return and more focused on supporting a cause. That said, the benefits are not always immediate. Tax credits vary by organization and situation, and pickup timelines may not be as flexible as other options.

Some popular car donation charities include Kars4Kids and Kidney Car. 

Selling through a Scrap Car Marketplace

An increasingly common option for getting rid of old and unwanted vehicles is selling through a scrap car marketplace or platform.  These services connect sellers with a network of local buyers to help them sell their car fast for top dollar.  

Rather than contacting individual yards, owners provide their vehicle information once and receive offers from multiple buyers. This approach can be useful for cars that no longer run, have high mileage, or are not suitable for private sale.

Marketplace-based selling typically includes:

• Online quotes based on vehicle details
  
  

• Offers from multiple buyers
  
  

• Pickup arranged by the buyer
  
  

• Payment at the time of pickup

Because prices are influenced by local demand and material value, offers may vary by location and vehicle type.  Regardless of price, this remains one of the easiest and most convenient ways to get rid of your old ride.  Sellers only need to answer a few simple questions. When they are ready, they can book their tow truck at their earliest convenience. 

The best option depends on your car’s condition, your timeline, and how much effort you want to invest. If your car runs well and you don’t mind the work, private selling may be worth exploring. If convenience matters most, trade-ins or donation could work.

But if your vehicle is no longer running or you want a fast, no-hassle way to turn it into cash, a scrap car selling platform often delivers the best balance of value and simplicity